When I’m delivering Makaton training, I often talk about how many questions I ask Raph when I go in to get him up in the morning.
“Hi! How are you? Did you sleep well? Are you ready to get up and start your day?”
Then I open the curtains. “Oh, I wonder what the weather’s like. Do we think it might rain today?”
“Would you like a bath or a shower this morning?”
And there are probably a few more I’ve forgotten.
In my head, I’m just having a lovely little chitchat with my son. Then I hear myself tell that story in training and think, blimey, give him a chance. He’s barely had time to answer the first question and I’m already asking him to forecast the weather.
I know which questions I’m asking just to fill the silence. How would Raph know? He could be getting ready to sign something about how he slept while I’m already on to the rain. By the time I ask whether he wants a bath or a shower, I’ve given him quite a lot to keep up with before he’s even out of bed.
What if I just said what I noticed?
“Morning, Raph. It’s good to see you.”
Then, as I open the curtains, “Oh, it’s really cloudy this morning.”
And then I can pause.
Raph might look towards the window, make a sound or sign something. He might bring up something else entirely, and we can talk about that. We can also just look out of the window together for a moment.
When I say “It’s really cloudy,” I’m sharing something I’ve noticed. I can sign cloudy while we’re looking at the clouds, and Raph can join in if he wants to.
Keep the questions you want an answer to
“Would you like a bath or a shower?” is a real choice. I can ask it, sign bath and shower or show Raph the symbols, then give him time to tell me what he wants.
I also catch myself asking questions when I already know the answer. When a dog walks past, it’s easy to point and say, “What’s that?” The person beside me might know perfectly well it’s a dog. They might be trying to show me that it’s wearing a coat, or that they’d like a bit more space as it comes past. If I’m waiting for them to say or sign dog, I could miss what they’re already telling me. And if they say nothing, I might assume they don’t know the word and ask them again. Now a little moment on a walk has turned into a quiz.
I could say, “Oh, look at that little dog!” Or, “That dog’s running!” Now I’ve got a chance to sign dog and running together, and the person beside me has room to show me what they’ve noticed. Maybe they’ve spotted that the dog’s heading straight for a puddle and we ought to move.
I’ll probably always be a chatterbox in the mornings. I can start with one small change. Open the curtains, say what I see and give Raph a moment to see what he makes of it.
Nic Pike is Director of Better Communication Together CIC and a Licensed Makaton Tutor and Tutor Training Facilitator. She writes about Makaton, accessible communication and inclusive practice, drawing on over 40 years' professional experience and lived experience as a parent of a Makaton user.
Better Communication Together CIC
Asking Questions? Try comments instead
When I’m delivering Makaton training, I often talk about how many questions I ask Raph when I go in to get him up in the morning.
“Hi! How are you? Did you sleep well? Are you ready to get up and start your day?”
Then I open the curtains. “Oh, I wonder what the weather’s like. Do we think it might rain today?”
“Would you like a bath or a shower this morning?”
And there are probably a few more I’ve forgotten.
In my head, I’m just having a lovely little chitchat with my son. Then I hear myself tell that story in training and think, blimey, give him a chance. He’s barely had time to answer the first question and I’m already asking him to forecast the weather.
I know which questions I’m asking just to fill the silence. How would Raph know? He could be getting ready to sign something about how he slept while I’m already on to the rain. By the time I ask whether he wants a bath or a shower, I’ve given him quite a lot to keep up with before he’s even out of bed.
What if I just said what I noticed?
“Morning, Raph. It’s good to see you.”
Then, as I open the curtains, “Oh, it’s really cloudy this morning.”
And then I can pause.
Raph might look towards the window, make a sound or sign something. He might bring up something else entirely, and we can talk about that. We can also just look out of the window together for a moment.
When I say “It’s really cloudy,” I’m sharing something I’ve noticed. I can sign cloudy while we’re looking at the clouds, and Raph can join in if he wants to.
Keep the questions you want an answer to
“Would you like a bath or a shower?” is a real choice. I can ask it, sign bath and shower or show Raph the symbols, then give him time to tell me what he wants.
I also catch myself asking questions when I already know the answer. When a dog walks past, it’s easy to point and say, “What’s that?” The person beside me might know perfectly well it’s a dog. They might be trying to show me that it’s wearing a coat, or that they’d like a bit more space as it comes past. If I’m waiting for them to say or sign dog, I could miss what they’re already telling me. And if they say nothing, I might assume they don’t know the word and ask them again. Now a little moment on a walk has turned into a quiz.
I could say, “Oh, look at that little dog!” Or, “That dog’s running!” Now I’ve got a chance to sign dog and running together, and the person beside me has room to show me what they’ve noticed. Maybe they’ve spotted that the dog’s heading straight for a puddle and we ought to move.
I’ll probably always be a chatterbox in the mornings. I can start with one small change. Open the curtains, say what I see and give Raph a moment to see what he makes of it.
If you’d like to try this in your own conversations, there are some practical ideas for commenting and giving someone time to join in in AssistiveWare’s guide to communication partner skills.
For families with young children, Speech and Language UK has a short guide that explains how “What’s that?” can feel like a test and gives everyday examples of what you could say instead. speechandlanguage.org.uk Make comments instead of asking questions
Nic Pike is Director of Better Communication Together CIC and a Licensed Makaton Tutor and Tutor Training Facilitator. She writes about Makaton, accessible communication and inclusive practice, drawing on over 40 years' professional experience and lived experience as a parent of a Makaton user.
© 2026 Better Communication Together CIC. All rights reserved.
This article is provided for personal learning and information. Please link to this page rather than copying or republishing the content.